Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Reports and reaction from the 2017-2018 season as Walsall finished 19th in League 1
- Cully
- Site Addict
- Posts: 4310
- Joined: Thu Dec 09, 2004 7:55 pm
- Location: Rugeley.........pronounced RUDGELEE apparently
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Walsall still well on top :D
It's all doom down at the Bescot :roll:
It's all doom down at the Bescot :roll:
-
Micky Saddler - UTS Veteran
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 1:34 pm
- Location: Willenhall
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Credit where credit is due we have looked very good tonight with some excellent football played..
Quite the relief as I was fearing the worst but we have shown some glimpses of really good play.
Morris the only stand out underperformer but it has for certain improved my mood following Saturday's result.
UTS
Quite the relief as I was fearing the worst but we have shown some glimpses of really good play.
Morris the only stand out underperformer but it has for certain improved my mood following Saturday's result.
UTS
-
dobbster71 - UTS Veteran
- Posts: 287
- Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 2:34 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
It's a pre-season friendly. A work-out is all it is!
-
Exile - Jobsworth
- Posts: 23623
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 7:06 pm
- Location: ヽ༼ຈل͜ຈ༽ノ
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Commentator on Bakayoko: 'it's fair to say his first touch isn't the best'. :D
Watched second half on the YouTube feed. Some good play, even with all the substitutions. Created little, looked solid. Made Villa look ordinary, so that's a plus, even if it is a meaningless friendly.
Watched second half on the YouTube feed. Some good play, even with all the substitutions. Created little, looked solid. Made Villa look ordinary, so that's a plus, even if it is a meaningless friendly.
- Pheasey_Saddler
- UTS Regular
- Posts: 192
- Joined: Mon Apr 09, 2007 8:17 pm
- Location: Pheasey, Walsall
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Decent result and performance. Gave a number of the kids a run out at the end too.
-
Kevlar - UTS Veteran
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2015 10:19 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Watching on youtube ....................... but can't see because that blokes shoulder keeps getting in the way.
But I did hear that one wayward shot was " on the way to Walsall City centre".
But I did hear that one wayward shot was " on the way to Walsall City centre".
- ShropsSaddler
- Glitterati
- Posts: 624
- Joined: Sun Apr 03, 2005 11:13 am
- Location: North of Scotland!
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Well I do hope some of the doom-mongers and panic merchants are going to come on here tonight and admit they were hasty?!? We played our first eleven for the first 70 minutes and that wasn't a bad display at all, against a decent Villa team. We're certainly not going to be troubling the top of the table without additions, but I doubt we're going to be relegated in September either!
First of all, credit where credit is due.....Whitney certainly knows a player when he sees one. Whoever had the idea to look up north is a genius, we appear to have signed two gems, one polished, the other unpolished. I'd reckon by the end of the season, both Devlin and Leahy will be loved by the fans.
And then, at centre half, he appears to have brought in two players who are both better than what we've got. Again, well done Whitney.
Goalkeeper - looks fine. Hard to tell, he didn't have too many saves to make, but what he did, he did well.
Two glaring problems as far as I'm concerned;
i) Up front - I'd humbly suggest that Makris would have offered more than Bakayoko did this evening. His effort was poor, his touch was awful and, when he did finally get the chance (through making a good run), he missed. I wish we could have seen Jackson on earlier because he seemed to offer a lot more in his time on the pitch. But neither is going to get the goals or lead the line in the way we need
ii) Morris - he's going further and further backwards in terms of development. And for those who say it's since Smith left, perhaps you'll remember that Smith wasn't playing him that often in our successful season because he clearly didn't rate him good enough. He's not.
That aside, Chambers may be getting old, but he's a wise head and you can see that the plan this season is to allow Devlin and Leahy to fly forward whilst Chambers drops into a back three. Good plan, saves his legs and uses his know-how. Oztumer will shine in League One again and Edwards has 5-10 goals in him this year. Cuvelier is the unknown - if he stays fit, he could be very important.
So, all in all, plenty to be pleased about but plenty still to do.
First of all, credit where credit is due.....Whitney certainly knows a player when he sees one. Whoever had the idea to look up north is a genius, we appear to have signed two gems, one polished, the other unpolished. I'd reckon by the end of the season, both Devlin and Leahy will be loved by the fans.
And then, at centre half, he appears to have brought in two players who are both better than what we've got. Again, well done Whitney.
Goalkeeper - looks fine. Hard to tell, he didn't have too many saves to make, but what he did, he did well.
Two glaring problems as far as I'm concerned;
i) Up front - I'd humbly suggest that Makris would have offered more than Bakayoko did this evening. His effort was poor, his touch was awful and, when he did finally get the chance (through making a good run), he missed. I wish we could have seen Jackson on earlier because he seemed to offer a lot more in his time on the pitch. But neither is going to get the goals or lead the line in the way we need
ii) Morris - he's going further and further backwards in terms of development. And for those who say it's since Smith left, perhaps you'll remember that Smith wasn't playing him that often in our successful season because he clearly didn't rate him good enough. He's not.
That aside, Chambers may be getting old, but he's a wise head and you can see that the plan this season is to allow Devlin and Leahy to fly forward whilst Chambers drops into a back three. Good plan, saves his legs and uses his know-how. Oztumer will shine in League One again and Edwards has 5-10 goals in him this year. Cuvelier is the unknown - if he stays fit, he could be very important.
So, all in all, plenty to be pleased about but plenty still to do.
-
saddla - Site Addict
- Posts: 2932
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 10:18 am
- Location: too far
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Hey you lot.
You're not allowed to say anything positive on here.
Bunch of Happy Clappers :mrgreen:
You're not allowed to say anything positive on here.
Bunch of Happy Clappers :mrgreen:
-
PT - Site Addict
- Posts: 3733
- Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2005 8:04 pm
- Location: Liverpool and skaville
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
That was OK. Second half scrappy with all the subs but a nice moment when "Simeon Jackson gives John Terry the slip". A sentence I don't think any of us thought we'd ever hear.
Good to see the M6 moving so well midweek.
All round a promising night.
Good to see the M6 moving so well midweek.
All round a promising night.
-
NEWPORT SADDLERS DAD - UTS Legend
- Posts: 2444
- Joined: Fri Mar 03, 2006 4:56 pm
- Location: SURROUNDED BY DINGLES
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
I'm happy with what I saw of the defence but we need a Bradshaw badly.
- Don Kiddick
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Thu Nov 10, 2005 1:12 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
saddla wrote:Hey you lot.
You're not allowed to say anything positive on here.
Bunch of Happy Clappers :mrgreen:
Be afraid, very afraid...the Dementors are hovering!
- saddlertd
- UTS Veteran
- Posts: 571
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2005 10:51 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
I watched the match on YouTube and was quite pleased with the performance. All the new guys played okay: Guthrie and Wilson looked solid at the back, Leahy and Devlin looked okay on the ball and Gillespie was not the disaster I was expecting. If only we had a decent striker!!! It was a good team performance: only Morris and Bakayoko were poor. I'd like to see more cover in midfield: someone who can play Central and right-side - I'm not convinced by the back-up players. So, let's get in a striker and some cover in midfield and we should reach mid-table mediocrity.
- El_Nombre
- UTS Legend
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 11:15 am
- Location: Next to Big Curly
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Just on the way back I think there are positives and negatives.
Just like any other preseason fixture you can't read anything into the result.
Positives I think the defence looked very solid. Guthrie was impressive for me. Looked commanding and Devlin was a live wire while he was on the pitch.
I like the 4-4-1-1. I actually think kouyar looks sharper than Morris on the right at the moment, he injected a bit of pace into the play.
Negatives, you have the glaringly obvious issue that everybody is completely aware of upfront and the second string worry me. Preston isn't good enough and I've seen better players at Hednesford Town than Reece Flanagan.
Think the biggest positive is that I think the club can stumble along for sometime yet without falling into the abyss if that is the set up :wink:
Just like any other preseason fixture you can't read anything into the result.
Positives I think the defence looked very solid. Guthrie was impressive for me. Looked commanding and Devlin was a live wire while he was on the pitch.
I like the 4-4-1-1. I actually think kouyar looks sharper than Morris on the right at the moment, he injected a bit of pace into the play.
Negatives, you have the glaringly obvious issue that everybody is completely aware of upfront and the second string worry me. Preston isn't good enough and I've seen better players at Hednesford Town than Reece Flanagan.
Think the biggest positive is that I think the club can stumble along for sometime yet without falling into the abyss if that is the set up :wink:
- m&m
- Glitterati
- Posts: 656
- Joined: Tue Dec 21, 2004 7:23 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Disagree with all of the comments on Kieran Morris.
Yes he can blow hot or cold but he's unpredictable,always willing to take on a man and likes to shoot.
If those efforts that hit a post or bar last season had gone in he would have easily have been in double figures.
Would always start for me.
Yes he can blow hot or cold but he's unpredictable,always willing to take on a man and likes to shoot.
If those efforts that hit a post or bar last season had gone in he would have easily have been in double figures.
Would always start for me.
- Wragbyred
- Glitterati
- Posts: 1060
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2012 7:42 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
El_Nombre wrote:Just on the way back I think there are positives and negatives.
Just like any other preseason fixture you can't read anything into the result.
Positives I think the defence looked very solid. Guthrie was impressive for me. Looked commanding and Devlin was a live wire while he was on the pitch.
I like the 4-4-1-1. I actually think kouyar looks sharper than Morris on the right at the moment, he injected a bit of pace into the play.
Negatives, you have the glaringly obvious issue that everybody is completely aware of upfront and the second string worry me. Preston isn't good enough and I've seen better players at Hednesford Town than Reece Flanagan.
Think the biggest positive is that I think the club can stumble along for sometime yet without falling into the abyss if that is the set up :wink:
Looks like Flanagan is going to be the boo boy again.
What exactly did he do wrong that doesn't even get him into Hednesfords team?
He was on 10 - 15 minutes, I don't remember seeing him do anything awful
- El_Nombre
- UTS Legend
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 11:15 am
- Location: Next to Big Curly
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Wragbyred wrote:El_Nombre wrote:Just on the way back I think there are positives and negatives.
Just like any other preseason fixture you can't read anything into the result.
Positives I think the defence looked very solid. Guthrie was impressive for me. Looked commanding and Devlin was a live wire while he was on the pitch.
I like the 4-4-1-1. I actually think kouyar looks sharper than Morris on the right at the moment, he injected a bit of pace into the play.
Negatives, you have the glaringly obvious issue that everybody is completely aware of upfront and the second string worry me. Preston isn't good enough and I've seen better players at Hednesford Town than Reece Flanagan.
Think the biggest positive is that I think the club can stumble along for sometime yet without falling into the abyss if that is the set up :wink:
Looks like Flanagan is going to be the boo boy again.
What exactly did he do wrong that doesn't even get him into Hednesfords team?
He was on 10 - 15 minutes, I don't remember seeing him do anything awful
I didn't see him find a single red shirt and he had plenty of opportunities...
Granted I was being a bit sarcastic with the Hednesford comment but he's nowhere near league 1
Edit: it was more like half an hour too, not 10-15
- coop63
- Glitterati
- Posts: 1054
- Joined: Fri Jan 09, 2015 10:06 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
I was very impressed tonight with some of the possession we controlled in the first half (with all the subs in the 2nd it's always going to change the shape of the game for both sides.. that said no one did too badly even if it was for a short period..)
Was very pleased with the new signings with Leahy looking particularly good - but all doing pretty well in my opinion.
For the record - many of those critical on here lately (of which I'm one) have been so about the leadership in the boardroom not the management of the playing staff (with the exception of the striker situation etc..) well done to all tonight and I'm sure most fans will be pretty happy after that game...
Was very pleased with the new signings with Leahy looking particularly good - but all doing pretty well in my opinion.
For the record - many of those critical on here lately (of which I'm one) have been so about the leadership in the boardroom not the management of the playing staff (with the exception of the striker situation etc..) well done to all tonight and I'm sure most fans will be pretty happy after that game...
- Pheasey_Saddler
- UTS Regular
- Posts: 192
- Joined: Mon Apr 09, 2007 8:17 pm
- Location: Pheasey, Walsall
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
El_Nombre wrote:Wragbyred wrote:El_Nombre wrote:Just on the way back I think there are positives and negatives.
Just like any other preseason fixture you can't read anything into the result.
Positives I think the defence looked very solid. Guthrie was impressive for me. Looked commanding and Devlin was a live wire while he was on the pitch.
I like the 4-4-1-1. I actually think kouyar looks sharper than Morris on the right at the moment, he injected a bit of pace into the play.
Negatives, you have the glaringly obvious issue that everybody is completely aware of upfront and the second string worry me. Preston isn't good enough and I've seen better players at Hednesford Town than Reece Flanagan.
Think the biggest positive is that I think the club can stumble along for sometime yet without falling into the abyss if that is the set up :wink:
Looks like Flanagan is going to be the boo boy again.
What exactly did he do wrong that doesn't even get him into Hednesfords team?
He was on 10 - 15 minutes, I don't remember seeing him do anything awful
I didn't see him find a single red shirt and he had plenty of opportunities...
Granted I was being a bit sarcastic with the Hednesford comment but he's nowhere near league 1
Edit: it was more like half an hour too, not 10-15
Not a massive fan of his but thought he did ok tonight. Saw him rob Amavi of the ball and find a red shirt shortly after he came on.
-
chunkster - Site Addict
- Posts: 3612
- Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2015 10:11 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Well i enjoyed that :D . I would be more worried if i were a glory-hunting Villa fan :lol: . We completely outplayed them for large parts of the game. My only criticism is that we looked woefully inept up front. If we do sign a half decent striker before the start of the season Baka will be lucky to get on the bench ... and just a message to Pedagogue and Swampster, I managed to escape arrest due to the fact my nephew's lad fell asleep for most of the game :mrgreen:
-
Pedagogue - Board Pedant
- Posts: 7293
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 3:21 pm
- Location: Can I fix it? Can I ****!
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Pheasey_Saddler wrote:El_Nombre wrote:Wragbyred wrote:Looks like Flanagan is going to be the boo boy again.
What exactly did he do wrong that doesn't even get him into Hednesford's team?
He was on 10 - 15 minutes, I don't remember seeing him do anything awful
I didn't see him find a single red shirt and he had plenty of opportunities...
Granted I was being a bit sarcastic with the Hednesford comment but he's nowhere near League 1
Edit: it was more like half an hour too, not 10-15
Not a massive fan of his but thought he did ok tonight. Saw him rob Amavi of the ball and find a red shirt shortly after he came on.
Quite. Some people have already made their minds up about Flanagan. Granted he has a lot to do, this season, but when fully fit and "on song", he is a quality footballer. Last season, he had problems coping with the physical side of the game. This, in turn forced him into errors, certain pillocks among our fans got on his back and his confidence drained away. As a result, he made even more mistakes. If our fans would all encourage our younger players, then they may develop into useful squad members.
He made several passes (the majority) to Walsall players. Please open your eyes when watching - it does make the experience easier! :mrgreen:
- El_Nombre
- UTS Legend
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 11:15 am
- Location: Next to Big Curly
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Pedagogue wrote:Pheasey_Saddler wrote:El_Nombre wrote:Wragbyred wrote:Looks like Flanagan is going to be the boo boy again.
What exactly did he do wrong that doesn't even get him into Hednesford's team?
He was on 10 - 15 minutes, I don't remember seeing him do anything awful
I didn't see him find a single red shirt and he had plenty of opportunities...
Granted I was being a bit sarcastic with the Hednesford comment but he's nowhere near League 1
Edit: it was more like half an hour too, not 10-15
Not a massive fan of his but thought he did ok tonight. Saw him rob Amavi of the ball and find a red shirt shortly after he came on.
Quite. Some people have already made their minds up about Flanagan. Granted he has a lot to do, this season, but when fully fit and "on song", he is a quality footballer. Last season, he had problems coping with the physical side of the game. This, in turn forced him into errors, certain pillocks among our fans got on his back and his confidence drained away. As a result, he made even more mistakes. If our fans would all encourage our younger players, then they may develop into useful squad members.
He made several passes (the majority) to Walsall players. Please open your eyes when watching - it does make the experience easier! :mrgreen:
Yeah I must have had my eyes closed for the majority because I saw the pointless chip straight to James Chester, the ball for Kouyar so over hit the keeper grabbed it. I saw him rob a Villa player only to give it him straight back in his own half. He even over hit a free kick from the halfway line to the left winger.
He made some passes under zero pressure sideways and backwards. I'm all for getting behind the players, I don't think I've ever "got on anybody's back before" and I will continue to encourage any player that pulls on a Walsall shirt during a game. But I just don't see it with him. I hope he proves me wrong.
It's funny how you are a happy clapper in one thread and a boo boy in another...
-
Pedagogue - Board Pedant
- Posts: 7293
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 3:21 pm
- Location: Can I fix it? Can I ****!
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
El_Nombre wrote:It's funny how you are a happy clapper in one thread and a boo boy in another ...
I'm neither.
-
chunkster - Site Addict
- Posts: 3612
- Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2015 10:11 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
The one thing that chesney did tonight was get stuck in, he showed willing and although he didn't set the game alight he didn't try to hide, The club have showed a lot of faith in the lad, so either they see something special in him? or they feel that they have invested a lot of time and money in him and are chasing it in the hope that he will repay them? :|
-
scott_powell - Site Addict
- Posts: 4045
- Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 3:23 pm
- Location: Clunge
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Flanagan looked okay for 30 seconds when he made a good challenge on Amavi I think it was. After that it was typical Flanagan. Gutless in the tackle. Terrible distribution. Awful positioning. Terrible hair colour.
Worse than Taundry.
Worse than Taundry.
- Larryhaggler1
- Posts: 59
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2015 11:34 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Agree with most of the comments above.
Happy with back 4, Leahy looks like he could be a brilliant find, well impressed.
Couveliler also looked fantastic and for me the pick f all the midfielders on show tonight on either team. He looked fit, sharp, composed and comfortable against Villa, keep him fit and he is certainly a championship level player.
Oztumer can also comfortably play at a higher level, he is so far ahead in thought than players like Morris it's blindingly obvious.
The negatives for me are Baka and Morris.
Baka In particular is Slow, never on the front foot, never seems to want to meet the ball and get in front of the defender and then the job he's actually paid for when clean through - misses the target !
Lots of positives but the glaring issue is the problem up front.
Happy with back 4, Leahy looks like he could be a brilliant find, well impressed.
Couveliler also looked fantastic and for me the pick f all the midfielders on show tonight on either team. He looked fit, sharp, composed and comfortable against Villa, keep him fit and he is certainly a championship level player.
Oztumer can also comfortably play at a higher level, he is so far ahead in thought than players like Morris it's blindingly obvious.
The negatives for me are Baka and Morris.
Baka In particular is Slow, never on the front foot, never seems to want to meet the ball and get in front of the defender and then the job he's actually paid for when clean through - misses the target !
Lots of positives but the glaring issue is the problem up front.
- El_Nombre
- UTS Legend
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 11:15 am
- Location: Next to Big Curly
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Pedagogue wrote:El_Nombre wrote:It's funny how you are a happy clapper in one thread and a boo boy in another ...
I'm neither.
I was talking about me and the labels that are thrown around on this board
-
chunkster - Site Addict
- Posts: 3612
- Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2015 10:11 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
on another note, who was Villas 25? thought he was superb reminded me of big dave that played for the Albion :)
-
Exile - Jobsworth
- Posts: 23623
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 7:06 pm
- Location: ヽ༼ຈل͜ຈ༽ノ
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
chunkster wrote:on another note, who was Villas 25? thought he was superb reminded me of big dave that played for the Albion :)
Chris Samba. Think they stole him from a basketball team!
- El_Nombre
- UTS Legend
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 11:15 am
- Location: Next to Big Curly
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
Exile wrote:chunkster wrote:on another note, who was Villas 25? thought he was superb reminded me of big dave that played for the Albion :)
Chris Samba. Think they stole him from a basketball team!
He looked like he will get ripped apart in the championship. The guy can't turn around!
-
chunkster - Site Addict
- Posts: 3612
- Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2015 10:11 pm
Re: Pre-season - Aston Villa (H) Tue 18 July, 7.45pm
:lol: the Harlem Globetrotters theme is running through my mind now :lol:Exile wrote:chunkster wrote:on another note, who was Villas 25? thought he was superb reminded me of big dave that played for the Albion :)
Chris Samba. Think they stole him from a basketball team!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 14 guests